Sunday, 28 March 2010

Datamining the taxis on Union Street

There's an NYT article on analysing GPS data feeds from taxis to build up a model of traffic flow and congestion.It's interesting but flawed. It only measures the routing options taxis take, which can be constrained by anti-taxi signage, such as as the "buses and bicycles only" bit of Nelson Street, leading to Union Street.

The continued presence of traffic lights here not only holds up buses and bicycles, it holds up taxis too.

Such as Taxi 107, SD06HSC photographed on Saturday March 18 2010 at 14:57.

Or taxi #686,  WV57FRU, seen on Saturday March 18 2010 at 14:57.
Or indeed,  taxi # 711, R329YON , seen on Saturday March 18 2010 at 14:57.
Because the taxis also need to make use of this road, the traffic lights should be adjusted to increase the scheduling time on this lane rather than just assuming one bus every minute. With this taxi flow rate, three vehicles every minute, the entire fleet of Bristol's taxicabs (at least 711, we would guess), would pass through this junction every four hours. The traffic lights do nothing but hold up taxis driving down the buses-only lane.

There: congestion analysis, no need for city wide GPS-instrumented taxis. Which is good for the taxi drivers, as it may log them doing things they aren't meant to.

3 comments:

  1. But those signs state 'pedal cycles and buses only'; n'aw?

    ReplyDelete
  2. It may look like that, but there is a taxi going through every 20 seconds, and as only cyclists ignore road signs, they must be doing it legally. Therefore you must have misread it and the sign says "buses and taxis only", it is the bicycles that are ignoring the sign, tax-dodging scofflaws that they are

    ReplyDelete
  3. http://www.avonandsomerset.police.uk/LocalPages/NewsDetails.aspx?nsid=20350&t=3&lid=43

    ReplyDelete

Commenters MUST NOT post spam, MUST NOT post requests for cross linking and MUST NOT post up requests for paid links. Such attempts SHALL result in one or more postings in which we MAY be rude or we MAY make fun of you and MAY include your public email address. Furthermore, we MAY report you to google for attempts at paid linking, who SHALL then punish your site.

Comments are closed after two days -after that they are moderated. You MUST be logged in to post.

This statement follows RFC2119 rules regarding the use of MUST, MUST NOT, MAY, and SHALL and MUST be treated as normative.